Dancing With the Stars Shocker: Harry Shum Jr. Eliminated Despite a Perfect 60/60 in the Semifinals
(Illustration: USA Current Affaires)
Television does not get much more brutal than this. On Tuesday night, November 17, Harry Shum Jr. and his professional partner Jenna Johnson delivered two flawless routines in the Dancing With the Stars Season 35 semifinals — and were sent home anyway. It was one of the most shocking eliminations in the show's history — how can a perfect score not be enough?
Shum Jr. and Johnson had been one of the strongest couples of the season, sitting at the top of the leaderboard for three consecutive weeks. On the judges' scorecards, they were unbeatable. Yet once the judges' scores were combined with the viewer votes, their journey ended one week before the finale — while a couple at the very bottom of the leaderboard danced on.
Two Perfect Scores — and Still No Finale
Shum Jr. and Johnson opened their semifinal night with a paso doble to "We Found Love," earning a perfect 30 from judges Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli. They followed it with a quickstep to the Glee version of "Valerie" — and earned another perfect 30. Their total of 60 out of 60 tied them with Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov for the highest judges' score of the night.
The quickstep carried an extra layer of meaning. The version of "Valerie" they danced to was sung by Shum Jr.'s late Glee castmate Naya Rivera, making the routine a tribute to his years on the show that made him a star. Shum Jr. said the song "means so much to so many people, including myself." Nobody in the ballroom expected it to be a farewell — judge Carrie Ann Inaba was visibly stunned as the results were announced.
How the Viewer Vote Overturned the Leaderboard
The explanation lies in how Dancing With the Stars counts its results. The outcome is decided by judges' scores and viewers' votes, each half counting for 50 percent. Showrunner Conrad Green has previously explained the system to The Hollywood Reporter: each couple receives ranking points for their place on the judges' leaderboard and ranking points for their place in the public vote, and the couple with the lowest combined total goes home. If two couples tie, the one with fewer public votes is eliminated.
That maths turned the semifinal upside down. Comedian Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold finished the night at the bottom of the judges' leaderboard with just 48 out of 60 — 24 for their jive and 24 for their quickstep. Yet they advanced to the finale. TV Insider's analysis suggests Wood could only have survived over Shum Jr. by receiving the most viewer votes of all six couples, tying them on seven ranking points each, with Wood winning the tie on votes. ABC does not publish vote totals, so exactly how close the result was is not known.
The full leaderboard tells the story: Shum Jr. and Johnson on 60, Glenn and Pashkov also on 60, Higgins and Ballas on 59, Frech and Karagach on 57, Ali and Ravnik on 55, and Wood and Arnold on 48. The couple at the top went home; the couple at the bottom stayed. Co-host Julianne Hough suggested viewers sometimes "don't necessarily vote" for couples who are doing very well.
Who Is Left — and When the Finale Airs
Five couples now head into the finale: Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas, Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach, Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik, and Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold. The three-hour live finale airs on Tuesday, November 24, at 8 p.m. ET on ABC and streams on Disney+, with each couple dancing three times — a dance chosen by the judges, an instant dance and a freestyle — before one celebrity lifts the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy.
Shum Jr.'s exit is only the third time in the show's history that a semifinalist has gone home after a perfect night. Gymnast Simone Biles was voted out in the season 24 semifinal in 2017 despite scoring 80 out of 80, and actor Juan Pablo Di Pace suffered the same fate in 2018, eliminated after a perfect 60 out of 60. In his goodbye, Shum Jr. thanked Johnson and called the show "one of the most beautiful experiences."
Live television keeps delivering surprises this awards season — Taylor Swift returns to the CMA Awards stage this week for her first performance there in 13 years — but few twists have stung quite like this one. Shum Jr. and Johnson did everything the judges asked of them, and it still was not enough. After the semifinal shock, nobody will dare to call the finale winner in advance.

Comments